Can organic agriculture feed the world stockdale et al 2001

While this study claims that organic yields and nitrogen fertility methods could feed the world, it does not forecast yields for any particular crop or region, nor does it claim that a global organic food system would necessarily increase food security anywhere. Food security depends on policies and prices as much as on yields.

Full
Answer

Can organic farming feed the world after all?

A Europe-based research team made headlines last week with its conclusion that organic farming can feed the world after all. However, few people took the time to read the small print in their paper, which shows that the researchers’ conclusion depends on several highly questionable assumptions.

Does the organic label help or hinder the search for sustainable agriculture?

In a logical world, organic and conventional farms would be able to cross-fertilize and learn from each other while benefiting from scientific innovations such as genetic modification. Regrettably, the polarizing effect of the organic label continues to be a hindrance rather than a help in the search for more sustainable agriculture.

How much more land is being used for organic conversion?

This shows, based on estimates culled from the existing scientific literature, that global organic conversion would lead to a 16-33 percent increase in land use, with a corresponding 8-15 percent increase in worldwide deforestation. So how do the authors achieve their headline conclusion?

Can organic food prevent a global food shortage?

Organic farmers can use non-synthetic pesticides such as copper and sulphur-based compounds (which can, in fact, be more toxic than their synthetic alternatives, though that’s a different story), but these products would struggle to prevent worldwide food shortages.


Can organic agriculture be able to feed the world?

The truth is that yes, organic can feed the world! Organic can compete with conventional yields and outperform conventional in adverse weather. Small farmers using organic methods have huge potential to expand global food production.


Why can’t organic farmers feed the world?

This nitrogen is ultimately derived from artificial fertilizers used to grow crops to feed the animals on conventional farms. In a worldwide organic scenario envisioned by the researchers, this would not be possible, so the nitrogen scarcity would be critical. This would lead to worldwide famine.


Can we feed the world with regenerative agriculture?

Summary: A review of the literature written between 2007 and 2020 indicates that small-scale regenerative agriculture can indeed feed the world, but would require economic, dietary, policy, and cultural shifts. In terms of yields, smallholder farming already accounts for well over half of the world’s food supply.


How does organic farming help the planet?

Organic farming is better for environmental health Organic farming is better for the environment because its practices involve less pollution soil erosion, and energy. Eliminating the use of pesticides in farming also benefits nearby birds and animals and people who live close to farms.


Can organic agriculture sustainably feed the world in 2050?

There is no clear-cut answer. Adrian Müller, senior researcher at the Research Institute of Organic Agriculture (FiBL), and his co-authors show that a 100% conversion to organic agriculture reduces nitrogen surplus and pesticide use but needs more land than conventional agriculture because it has lower yields.


Can organic farming produce enough food for all?

Despite farmers currently producing more than enough to feed the entire population, some 800 million people still go hungry. Total organic could exacerbate that problem. … Current animal supply feeds around 800 million, but under total organic agriculture, animal supply would feed 900 million people.


Do farmers really feed the world?

They conclude that, globally, only 55% of crop calories feed people directly, 36% go to feed livestock and 9% are used to produce biofuels. In the US, where large industrial farms dominate the scene, the situation is much worse: only 27% of crop calories feed people directly and 67% feed livestock.


Why can’t we feed the world?

Our inability to feed the entirety of the world’s population is mostly due to food waste. Globally, 30–40% of all food is wasted. In less developed countries, this waste is due to lack of infrastructure and knowledge to keep food fresh.


Do we really need industrial agriculture to feed the world?

It’s true that the human population is growing, but without intensive industrial practices that flood markets, destroy soil, and exploit farmers, many communities wouldn’t need a hero to provide food. They could simply feed themselves: already, 70-80% of people worldwide are being fed by smaller farms.


How does organic food benefit the environment?

Organic farming tends to be better for the environment. Organic farming practices may reduce pollution, conserve water, reduce soil erosion, increase soil fertility, and use less energy. Farming without synthetic pesticides is also better for nearby birds and animals as well as people who live close to farms.


How is organic farming better for the economy?

In general, organic farmers rely on resources recycled on-farm and on management practices rather than on purchased fertilizers and pesticides. This approach can significantly reduce some costs of production. On the other hand, those inputs that organic farmers do buy tend to be more expensive than conventional inputs.


Why organic farming is much in demand today?

The demand for organic farming is increasing as organic food is not cultivated with the help of pesticides and excludes Genetically Modified Organism (GMO). Organic food includes high levels of nutrition and is fresher to consume.


Why is organic matter important?

The higher content of organic matter also makes organic soil less compact so that root systems can penetrate more deeply to find moisture. These results highlight the importance of organic farming methods and their potential to avert future crop failures both in the US and in the rest of the world.


Is organic farming sustainable?

A survey of recent studies comparing the productivity of organic practices to conventional agriculture provides an excellent example of the wide range of benefits we can expect from a conversion to sustainable agricultural methods. The results clearly show that organic farming accomplishes many of the FAO’s sustainability aims, as well as showing promise in increasing food production ability.


Why are organic farmers important?

By abstaining from most toxic synthetic inputs, organic farmers protect the environment and prioritize soil health, wildlife habitat, clean and air water, and nutrient-dense foods. Their emphasis is typically less on maximizing crop yields and more on creating healthy, resilient ecosystems.


How does a small scale farmer help the ecosystem?

The small-scale farmer is also nearly guaranteed to grow and raise diverse crops and livestock, enhancing biodiversity, a crucial marker of healthy ecosystems.


What do we need to feed the world?

To truly feed the world, we’re going to need more foods that provide complete nutrition and more farmers to grow it. Currently, our food system overproduces grains, fats, and sugars and underproduces the vitamins, minerals, and proteins vital for human health.


How can small farmers help the world?

There is huge potential in small farmers in the developing world for increasing food production and global food security by growing diverse and nutrient-dense foods. 40% of the world’s current crop production comes from these small farmers, and they are poised to make a big difference. 10


Can organic food feed the world?

The truth is that yes, organic can feed the world! Organic can compete with conventional yields and outperform conventional in adverse weather. Small farmers using organic methods have huge potential to expand global food production.


Can we feed the world organically?

The truth is that yes, organic can feed the world!


Is agriculture going in the wrong direction?

In contrast, agriculture’s environmental performance is going in the wrong direction: Aggregate impacts are increasing and must drop sharply over the coming decades.” 5. Yes, we need to produce more food. But more importantly, we need to mitigate farming’s harmful effects on the environment—fast.


Why will the divide become ever greater in the future?

As Michael Le Page has pointed out in New Scientist: “This divide will become ever greater in the future, because the organizations that set the rather arbitrary standards for what counts as ‘organic’ have firmly rejected the technology showing the greatest promise for reducing farming emissions: genetic modification.”.


Does synthetic pesticides have a halo effect?

To my knowledge, none of the published studies account for the halo effect of existing synthetic pesticide use, which helps protect neighboring organic farms from severe pest outbreaks by area-wide suppression of pest populations. The same goes for diseases.


Can organic farming feed the world?

Organic farming can feed the world — until you read the small print. Picking organic basil. Photo by Organic Farming Research Assocation. A Europe-based research team made headlines last week with its conclusion that organic farming can feed the world after all. However, few people took the time to read the small print in their paper, …


Do organic farms have halo effect?

Organic farms benefit from ‘halo effect’ in controlling pests. Photo by Genetic Literacy Project. A similar challenge applies for synthetic pesticides, which are noisily avoided in organic farming. To my knowledge, none of the published studies account for the halo effect of existing synthetic pesticide use, which helps protect neighboring organic …

Leave a Comment