How are gmos different from traditional agricultural practices


Conventional breeding relies on mixing characteristics from different populations within a species and then selecting from a plants natural complement of genetic elements. However genetic engineering relies on inserting genetic elements, and they end up in random locations, which can disrupt complex gene interactions.

How are GMOs different from traditional agricultural practices quizlet?

How is the technology of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) radically different from traditional methods of crop breeding and animal husbandry? GMO technology allows DNA from any organism, even human DNA, to be inserted into the genetic code of a crop plant or farm animal.

How are GMOs different?

A genetically modified organism contains DNA that has been altered using genetic engineering. Genetically modified animals are mainly used for research purposes, while genetically modified plants are common in today’s food supply.

How have GMOs changed agriculture practices?

Increased efficiency and economics of scale allow farmers to control planting practices and machinery on more land. The median size of a farm increased from 589 to 1105 acres between 1982 and 2007, predominantly in the Corn Belt region [5].

How does genetically modified food production differ from traditional selective breeding?

In selective breeding, the individuals have to be from the same species. In GMO the scientists create new combinations of genes. In selective breeding, genes combine on their own. The first GMO was produced in 1973.

What are GMOs in agriculture?

A GMO (genetically modified organism) is a plant, animal, or microorganism that has had its genetic material (DNA) changed using technology that generally involves the specific modification of DNA, including the transfer of specific DNA from one organism to another.

What are the advantages and disadvantages of genetically modified foods?

The pros of GMO crops are that they may contain more nutrients, are grown with fewer pesticides, and are usually cheaper than their non-GMO counterparts. The cons of GMO foods are that they may cause allergic reactions because of their altered DNA and they may increase antibiotic resistance.

What are the advantages benefits of the GMO?

The possible benefits of genetic engineering include:More nutritious food.Tastier food.Disease- and drought-resistant plants that require fewer environmental resources (such as water and fertilizer)Less use of pesticides.Increased supply of food with reduced cost and longer shelf life.Faster growing plants and animals.More items…•

How do GMOs benefit farmers?

GMOs help farmers reduce agriculture’s impact on the environment and protect the land for future generations. Over the last 20 years, GMOs have helped to reduce pesticide applications by 8.1 percent and increase crop yields by 22 percent.

Are GMO sustainable agriculture?

Shooting for sustainability Many GMO crops grow better than their non-GMO counterparts under environmental stresses and are thus able to ward off crop diseases and pests. GMO crops can grow with less water, energy and pesticides—all environmentally sustainable benefits.

How is GMO different from traditional plant breeding?

Conventional breeding relies on mixing characteristics from different populations within a species and then selecting from a plants natural complement of genetic elements. However genetic engineering relies on inserting genetic elements, and they end up in random locations, which can disrupt complex gene interactions.

How is biotechnology different from traditional plant breeding?

Cross-breeding has created many new and unique varieties. plant breeding process by altering or inserting specific genes into a new living organism. Scientists can insert individual genes from one living organism into another using biotechnology methods. DNA does not need to come from a closely related species.

How is GM different to selective breeding?

GMO is an artificially manipulated breeding method whereas selective breeding involves a natural breeding method. GMO can be intra as well as inter-species whereas selective breeding only occurs in intraspecies. GMO is a sub-type of genetic engineering whereas selective breeding is a sub-type of artificial selection.

Why are GMOs used in agriculture?

GMOs in agriculture are used as tools for research and production of molecules of interest. In addition, transgenesis allows plants to be modified to give them new traits in order to improve production and product resistance. This method is faster than traditional varietal selection but can be harmful for environment.

When were GMOs invented?

The Birth of Modern Genetic Modification. An enormous breakthrough in GMO technology came in 1973, when Herbert Boyer and Stanley Cohen worked together to engineer the first successful genetically engineered (GE) organism.

Why is Monsanto so important?

As Monsanto started to focus more on biotechnology, the company used “feeding the world hunger” as one of the main reasons behind the need for GMOs. Monsanto also invented a new genetically modified crop that was resistant to its best selling herbicide Roundup.

Why are GMOs bad for us?

In fact with GMOs we lose more varieties of vegetables and fruits than the number we produce. Gathering every “useful” characteristic means having only one type of tomato, or salad, resistant to every insects and viruses. This “monoculture” is the main problem linked to GMOs and is one enormous source of species extinction.

What foods are genetically engineered?

More than 60% of all processed foods on the supermarket shelves—including pizza, chips, cookies, ice cream, salad dressing, corn syrup, and baking powder—contain ingredients from engineered soybeans, corn, or canola.

What was Monsanto’s main product?

Following the Second World War, Monsanto championed the use of chemical pesticides in agriculture. Its major agrochemical products have included the herbicides 2,4,5-T, DDT, Lasso and Agent Orange, which was widely used as a defoliant by the U.S.

How many different crop designs have passed through the federal review process?

More than 50 different “designer” crops have passed through a federal review process, and about a hundred more are undergoing field trials.

How to make a GMO plant?

To produce a GMO plant, scientists first identify what trait they want that plant to have, such as resistance to drought, herbicides, or insects. Then, they find an organism (plant, animal, or microorganism) that already has that trait within its genes. In this example, scientists wanted to create insect-resistant corn to reduce the need to spray pesticides. They identified a gene in a soil bacterium called Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), which produces a natural insecticide that has been in use for many years in traditional and organic agriculture.

What was the first GMO?

1990s The first wave of GMO produce created through genetic engineering becomes available to consumers: summer squash, soybeans, cotton, corn, papayas, tomatoes, potatoes, and canola. Not all are still available for sale.

What is the 1992 FDA policy?

1992 FDA policy states that foods from GMO plants must meet the same requirements, including the same safety standards, as foods derived from traditionally bred plants.

Why do scientists grow corn?

In the laboratory, scientists grow the new corn plant to ensure it has adopted the desired trait (insect resistance). If successful, scientists first grow and monitor the new corn plant (now called Bt corn because it contains a gene from Bacillus thuringiensis) in greenhouses and then in small field tests before moving it into larger field tests. GMO plants go through in-depth review and tests before they are ready to be sold to farmers.

How to get insect resistance trait from corn?

Next, scientists use tools to insert the gene into the DNA of the plant. By inserting the Bt gene into the DNA of the corn plant, scientists gave it the insect resistance trait.

What are some examples of modification methods?

For example, early farmers developed cross-breeding methods to grow corn with a range of colors, sizes, and uses.

What is the process of identifying a gene?

Identifying the genetic information—or “gene”—that gives an organism (plant, animal, or microorganism) a desired trait. Copying that information from the organism that has the trait. Inserting that information into the DNA of another organism. Then growing the new organism.

What is GMO food?

GMO Foods and Genetic Engineering. Genetically engineered (GE) or genetically modified (GM) foods are produced from plants and animals that have had changes made to their DNA, which introduce or modify genetic traits. Most packaged foods contain genetically modified organisms (GMOs) engineered to be resistant to herbicides and pests; corn, …

Who approves GMOs?

In the US, regulatory approvals for GMOs are a complicated patchwork of the Food and Drug Administration for pharmaceutical developments, the Environmental Protection Agency for insecticide uses and the USDA for food crops.

Why are GMOs bad?

Concerns about GMOs range from their safety to how genetically modified plants’ pollen effects the environment, to the increasing use of herbicides associated with their use, with decreasing effectiveness . Polls show that consumers want mandatory labels on foods containing GE ingredients. 1.

How have GMOs impacted the environment?

One of the major ways that GMOs have impacted the environment, therefore, has been in a mass of side effects stemming from increased pesticide use , including compromised water quality, loss of biodiversity and threats to human health.

Why do farmers use GE seeds?

Farmers adopt GE seeds and their attendant herbicides ostensibly to make farming easier and more profitable. However, GE seeds cost a lot more than conventional seeds (up to $150 more per bag, according to one report) plus the cost of herbicides.

What are the cells of an organism?

All living organisms are made up of cells, within which are strings of DNA molecules possessing instructions to make genes, which form a unique blueprint determining how an organism grows, develops, looks and lives. Genes make up about one percent of the DNA sequence; the rest is responsible for regulating when and how quantities of proteins are made. 2

Why is biotechnology important?

The biotech industry claims that this chemical-based agricultural technology and biotechnology is necessary to feed a growing world population, increase crop yields and adapt to a changing climate. Herbicide-resistant crops do not require tilling, which leaves carbon in the ground and is better for soil structure, and proponents claim that they require less pesticide application than non-GE crops. However, this does not tell the whole story. These crops have actually driven up the use of herbicides like glyphosate, thereby increasing weed resistance and leading to the reintroduction of more potent herbicides. 17 These false narratives are perpetuated by biotech and other agribusiness corporations, but also by land grant universities (which receive more funding from agrochemical companies than public dollars, many agricultural scientists and farm organizations. 1819

What is organic agriculture?

Organic agriculture is an ecological production management system that promotes and enhances biodiversity, biological cycles, and soil biological activity. It is based on minimal use of off-farm inputs and on management practices that restore, maintain, or enhance ecological harmony. The primary goal of organic agriculture is to optimize …

What is organic farming?

Organic farmers generally use less toxic chemicals and pay closer attention to soil health–organic matter, nutrients and microbial activity. Conventional agricultural intensification has a historically notorious record of wasting water, overusing fertilizers and pesticides, and polluting habitats.

Why is conservation tillage important?

Conservation tillage practices improve soil health, reduce soil erosion, and preserve soil moisture. Conservation tillage simply wasn’t possible in sugarbeet before the introduction of Roundup Ready varieties, because intensive tillage was needed to obtain adequate weed control in the crop.

Why did Chipotle stop using soy oil?

Chipotle abandoned the use of GMO soy oil, switching to what it claimed was ‘more sustainable’ sunflower because, it stated, soy products have been linked to the growth of herbicide-resistant so-called superweeds which have proliferated with the increased usage of glyphosate.

What crops use less water?

It often uses less water; and some GM crops , such as insect resistant Bt corn, soybean, cotton and eggplant, require less chemical pesticides than their organic counterparts. Chemicals are only part of the sustainability equation. Eco-responsibility means different things to different experts.

Why do people spend more on organic food?

Many consumers spend more for organic food to avoid genetically modified products in part because they believe that “industrial agriculture” endangers the environment and produces less nutritious food. Many agroecology supporters also argue that a global move towards sustainable, organic agriculture is necessary to save the planet from the misuse of harmful chemicals and protect fragile soil ecosystems. Currently about 1 percent of the world food supply is grown using the kind of organic principles embraced in the United States and Europe.

How much of the world’s food is grown organically?

Currently about 1 percent of the world food supply is grown using the kind of organic principles embraced in the United States and Europe. When assessing sustainability, one should consider what organic farming is and is not.

Why are people against GMOs?

The reasons for this opposition are complex and multifaceted, but from what is articulated and communicated by those who oppose GMOs, they are based on the perception that such crops pose an unacceptable risk to both human health and the environment. Such sentiment exists even though there have been no adverse health or environmental affects from the almost four billion acres of GMO crops grown since their introduction in 1996. Several National Research Council committees and European Commissions (as well as joint commissions) have concluded that with the extensive scientific inquiry into the safety issues surrounding the adoption of GM crops, genetic engineering using biotechnology is no different from conventional breeding in terms of unintended consequences to the environment or animal and human health. 33 The European Commission funded more 50 research programs from 2001–2010 to address concerns regarding the use of GM crops to reach this same determination. 34 Nicolia et al. 24 constructed a database of 1,783 scientific original research papers, reviews, relevant opinion articles, and reports published between 2002 and October of 2010 on GMO safety issues, and reviewed the contents to generate a comprehensive overview of the accumulated knowledge. The overall conclusion of this mammoth undertaking was that “the scientific research conducted so far has not detected any significant hazards directly connected with the use of GM crops.

What is the challenge of GM crops?

To meet the challenge of improving yields requires a constant commitment to generating a steady supply of improved cultivars and lines for all major crops. Conventional breeding cannot keep pace with what is required; to meet the targets biotechnology and the production of genetically-modified (GM) crops is filling the gap. However, there are still concerns as to the safety of GM crops for human consumption and the environment. In this review I explore the need for GM crops, the way they are produced, and their impact and safety.

How long has GM been around?

It has been thirty years since the first genetically engineered plants were generated, and it has been eighteen years since the first introduction of a transgenic crop into U.S. agriculture. Since their emergence the acreage planted with GM crops has steadily increased such that in 2013, 433 million acres (175.2 hectares) of land were dedicated to their production, 56% of which were grown in developing countries. 28 As of 2013, a total more than four billion acres of GMA crops have been grown in 27 countries world-wide, primarily in corn, soybean and cotton, although new crops are being introduced at an increasing rate. The economic benefits of the deployment of these crops have been substantial. Mannion and Morse 29 report that on a global level, from 1996 to 2006, GM crops increased farm income by $40.7 billion, occurring in both developed (47%) and developing agricultures (53%). In the following six years (as of 2012) the global increase in farm income from GM crops had almost tripled that of the previous 10 years to reach $116 billion. 28, 30 Both studies estimate that 42% of this economic gain is derived from the increased yield associated with lower weed and pest damage as well as superior genetics. The remaining 58% accrued from a decrease in production costs (decreased herbicide and pesticide costs and a reduction in tillage). These figures indicate that the underlying agronomic benefits derived from GM crops are equally impressive: with a global yield increase of 377 million tons from 1996 to 2012. In 2012 the increase in yield attributed to GM crops for the U.S. was 47 million tons. 28, 30 Brooks and Barfoot 30 estimate that to attain an equal yield increase to that delivered by GM crops between 1996 and 2012, an additional 303 million acres (123 million hectares) of conventional crops would have been required. As James 28 postulates that to attain this extra land industrial nations would have to use marginal lands that are generally characterized by poor soils (requiring substantial inputs such as fertilizer and irrigation) and developing countries would primarily target tropical forests. Certainly such an added conversion of land to agricultural purposes would have serious ecological and environmental impacts regardless of what part of the world it is acquired.

How does GM affect biodiversity?

The adoption of GM herbicide tolerant crops does alter the biodiversity of plant populations (weeds) in agricultural ecosystems and some of the insects and other organisms that rely upon them but this is related to weed management and herbicide use not the GM crop. Alterations in biodiversity also occur in conventional agriculture where weed management strategies are employed. 48 Nevertheless there is great deal of evidence that the adoption of GM herbicide tolerant crops has had a beneficial impact on the environment. The conversion of natural habitat and ecosystems to urban development and agriculture is clearly the most detrimental aspect of human activity as it relates to environmental impact and loss of biodiversity. As yields increase with the adoption of GM crops, as discussed previously, the need to dedicate land for agriculture decreases. Apart from the reduced conversion of land to agricultural use the emergence of GM herbicide tolerant crops has accelerated and enabled the adoption of conservative tillage (no-till and reduced-till) practices. 30, 45, 48 Such practices enhance soil quality, reduce water run-off, conserves nutrients, increases water infiltration, and contributes to a reduction in greenhouse gases.

How does DNA transfer to plant cells?

17 By far the most common and widely used technique for direct DNA transfer is particle bombardment. Microparticle bombardment , also known as biolistics or the “gene gun”, was first developed by Sanford in the late 1980s 18 using pressurized helium to fire gold or tungsten microparticles (diameter between .5 and 1.0 μm) coated with the engineered gene of interest as naked DNA into the plant tissue at high velocities. The pressure used to project the microparticles varied depending upon the target tissues but could go up as high as 2,200 psi: the higher the velocity of the particles, the deeper the penetration into the target tissue. The primary targeted tissues were embryonic tissues from the seed or meristems. The engineered gene was delivered as a high copy number plasmid (a circle of DNA capable of replicating in a bacterial host during the engineering process) and once in the cell was capable of integrating into the plant genome, often in multiple copies. Although the equipment has become more sophisticated and the microprojectiles have changed with time, microparticle bombardment still operates on the same principles as the original Sanford “gene gun”. Microparticle bombardment has been successfully used to produce transgenic plants in a wide-range of crops including all of the cereals, some tuber crops, and trees. It has the advantage over other methods in that it can be used to transfer large DNA fragments and has even been used to transfer whole chromosomes and multiple independently engineered genes at the same time. 19

How has Bt-GM changed the world?

The deployment of Bt-GM crops has resulted in a significant decrease in the use of chemical pesticides in all countries where they have been adopted, along with the reduction in environmental impact and associated human exposure. 29 – 31 The reductions are both in quantities of active ingredient and the overall field EIQs for each major crop. In the U.S. the use of Bt-GM maize reduced the amount of pesticide used on corn to target corn borers and root-worms by 80% and the field EIQ load by 54%. Since 1966 the overall decrease in pesticide use on corn was 45% with a reduction of 38% for the field IEQ load. Where data is available, the reductions in total pesticide use and EIQ in all countries that have adopted Bt-maize cultivation. Similar figures are also available for Bt-cotton and other crops. 30 The beneficial economic, environmental, and human health effects resulting from a reduction in pesticide use (and reduced need for toxic pesticide alternatives) can be directly attributed to the ability of GM technologies to contain the pesticide within the plant that is targeted by specific insects (or other invertebrate pests) and to deliver the pesticide only to those pests that ingest the tissues of the plant. The reduction in the need to expose the environment and workers to chemical sprays is clearly a positive outcome of the deployment of GM crops.

What is golden rice?

Golden Rice (far right, yellow color) was envisioned as a non-commercial venture to deliver a cheap and effective (easy to distribute and deliver) dietary source of vitamin A for areas of the world where rice is the staple. Source: Wikipedia

How does genetic engineering affect agriculture?

Genetic engineering is a tool to speed up breeding for new varieties , which can help farmers and agricultural systems adapt to rapidly changing physical growing conditions, technology, and global markets. We review the current scientific literature and present the potential of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) from the perspectives of various stakeholders. GMOs increase yields, lower costs, and reduce the land and environmental footprint of agriculture. The benefits of this technology are shared among innovators, farmers, and consumers. Developing countries and poor farmers gain substantially from GMOs. Agricultural biotechnology is diverse, with many applications having different potential impacts. Its regulation needs to balance benefits and risks for each application. Excessive precaution prevents significant benefits. Increasing access to the technology and avoidance of excessive regulation will allow it to reach its potential.

Is mandatory labeling of GMOs on products unfair?

… According to Zilberman et al. (2018), mandatory labeling of GMOs on products is not only inefficient but also unfair. The authors thus resist a situation that leads to a misperception of genetically modified foods, as labeling is a misleading opinion, which exacerbates the existence of the concept of GMOs. …

What are the traits of GM crops?

Genetically modified (GM) crops have been rapidly adopted by the American farmer. Transgenic traits in corn and soybeans conferring the ability to resist the herbicide glyphosate are an omnipresent variety found in fields today. Released in the 1990s, the Roundup Ready trait (see this article) is present in nearly 90 percent of soybeans and 70 percent of corn grown in the United States [1]. The Bt trait, expressing the Cry1ab protein (see this article ), makes the transformed plant resistant to insects, and this trait is found in nearly 80 percent of US corn [2]. These traits are often stacked, meaning the plant has both insect and herbicide tolerance [3].

How has agriculture facilitated the consolidation of farming operations?

These agricultural practices have also facilitated the consolidation of farming operations. Increased efficiency and economics of scale allow farmers to control planting practices and machinery on more land. The median size of a farm increased from 589 to 1105 acres between 1982 and 2007, predominantly in the Corn Belt region [5]. Even with such drastic growth, 96 percent of crop-producing farms today remain family-operated [3].

How does herbicide technology help farmers?

Since farmers only have to spray one broad-spectrum herbicide with this technology, complicated herbicide spraying regimens, as well as manual weed removal, can be avoided. This allows farmers to expand their operation or spend more time off the farm with family or on other jobs.

How does technology affect farming?

Technology continues to shape the lives of those that pursue farming as a career. Genetically modified crops are just one tool in a growing arsenal that allows farmers to maximize yields in both row-crop and vegetable agriculture.

What are the benefits of small vegetable farms?

Small farms benefit from increased crop density and agricultural intensity, as well as the fact that genetically modified niche crops of lower yield can carry unique benefits. GM apples suppress fruit browning; GM beans, squash, peppers, and tomatoes resist viruses; GM melons and tomatoes allow controlled fruit ripening; and GM potatoes halt both insects and leaf wilt [13]. These varieties can fill niches in the small farmer’s operation where traditionally-bred varieties fail.

Why did the population of farming counties stagnate in 2004?

I’m not the only one who left the farm; the population of farming counties began to stagnate in 2004 and declined from 2010 onwards due to increased migration out of the region and diminishing interest in rural development [7]. By decreasing fieldwork costs and introducing larger machinery to spray and harvest a uniform crop, genetically modified organisms have reduced the need for a labor force in rural areas. Agricultural companies are currently developing drones and other remote-controlled tractors, planters, and sprayers to combat the dearth of laborers in large farming operations [8].

Will Farms of the Future run on robots?

8. Farms of the Future Will Run on Robots and Drones


Simple Selection



Natural Mutations

Induced Mutations

Creating New Varieties by Genetic Modification

Benefits and Risks Associated with Genetic Modification

  • Developers of genetically modified crops defend their work, citing reduced pesticide use and improved yields. Genetic modification has also produced plants with higher nutrient levels than their conventionally bred counterparts. Although genetic modification has been around for almost three decades and the U.S. Food and Drug Administration has deem…

See more on

What’s Next?

What Consumers Can Do

Leave a Comment