Why the us should not increase organic agriculture


Organic crops may have to contend with more weeds and pests than conventional crops, so they may produce more natural toxins to ward the weeds off, as potatoes do with a chemical called solanine. Additionally, the use of manure fertilisers may increase the risk of contamination by microbes such as E.coli. Farmers’ Health and Safety

There is a huge downside because of the extra land that is being used to grow organic crops,” said Stefan Wirsenius, an associate professor at Chalmers. “If we use more land for food, we have less land for carbon sequestration. The total greenhouse gas impact from organic farming is higher than conventional farming.”Oct 22, 2019


Why is organic farming on the rise in the US?

The rise in organic farming in the U.S. coincides with Americans’ growing appetite for organic food over the past few decades. According to the USDA’s Economic Research Service , retail sales of organic foods expanded rapidly from 1994 to 2014.

Is organic farming bad for the environment?

Some of the farming practices that are commonly employed on organic farms are very positive from an environmental perspective, but those practices are also used by progressive “conventional” growers.

Is it hard to switch from conventional to organic farming?

It hasn’t been an easy switch. He’s navigated challenges through trial and error because—despite the growth of organic agriculture—there isn’t a mentor or a playbook to follow. On a conventional farm, he says, “I can hire sprayers to come out and spray our whole farm within a day, and then come and spread the nutrients, the fertilizer.

Can organic agriculture help rural America’s job crisis?

Organic agriculture could help fulfill the elusive quest for more jobs in rural America: A conventional farm of similar size could support one family, with some seasonal employment opportunities; his organic farm supports five families.


What are the disadvantages of organic agriculture?

Disadvantages of Organic GardeningSignificant costs at the beginning.May not be suitable for growing on a large scale.Pest issues.Products may be too expensive for poor people.Regulatory standards may be hard to meet.High certification costs.Small farmers may go out of business.Organic farming can be time-consuming.More items…

What are the major problems in promoting organic agriculture?

Major Problems and Constraints for Organic Farming in IndiaLack of Awareness: … Output Marketing Problems: … Shortage of Bio-mass: … Inadequate Supporting Infrastructure: … High Input Costs: … Marketing Problems of Organic Inputs: … Low Yields:

What is the bad impact negative effects of organic farming?

ENVIRONMENTAL EFFECTS OF ORGANIC FARMING. Agricultural production contributes to various environmental problems such as climate change, biodiversity loss, soil degradation, and water pollution (Foley et al. 2011).

How is organic farming bad for the economy?

Labor needs on organic farms are usually greater than on comparable conventional farms. In addition to requiring more labor in the field, organic farmers need to keep more detailed records than their conventional counterparts, which adds to total labor demands.

What are the pros and cons of organic farming?

Here are the pros and cons of organic farming.Pros of Organic Farming. High nutrition values. Better taste. Improved human health. Environmental sustainability. Food security. … Cons of Organic Farming. Diminished productivity in the long-term. Time consuming. Skills. Organic products are extremely expensive.

What is organic farming advantages and disadvantages?

Comparison Table for Advantages and Disadvantages of Organic FarmingAdvantagesDisadvantagesClimate friendly and easier on the environmentNot 100% organicSustainable and generates lower carbon footprintPesticides and other harmful chemicals may still be present8 more rows•Mar 9, 2022

Should we increase organic agriculture?

Organic can compete with conventional yields and outperform conventional in adverse weather. Small farmers using organic methods have huge potential to expand global food production. And only organic methods actively regenerate resources and protect the environment from pollution and toxic waste.

Is organic farming a threat to the environment?

Organic farming is widely considered to be a far more sustainable alternative when it comes to food production. The lack of pesticides and wider variety of plants enhances biodiversity and results in better soil quality and reduced pollution from fertilizer or pesticide run-off.

What is the USDA’s goal for organic certification?

USDA has a current goal to increase the number of certified organic operations and is expanding programs and services for organic producers and handlers. Funding for organic research, certification cost-share assistance, and other programs has been increasing since 2002, when national organic standards were implemented.

Where was the 2011 USDA conference held?

In 2011, USDA held a major conference in Washington, DC to examine findings from research on the agronomic, economic, ecological, and quality-of-life performance of organic farming systems. Conference proceedings are published in the online interdisciplinary journal Crop Management .

Is organic food growing?

farmers across a broad range of products. Organic products are now available in nearly 3 of 4 conventional grocery stores, and often have substantial price premiums over conventional products (see data on Organic Prices ).

How much did organic farming make in 2016?

As the number of organic farms has increased, so too have sales of certified organic products: U.S. farms and ranches sold nearly $7.6 billion in certified organic goods in 2016, more than double the $3.5 billion in sales in 2011. Still, organic farming makes up a small share of U.S. farmland overall. There were 5 million certified organic acres of …

How many people say organic food is bad?

About four-in-ten U.S. adults (39%) say that most or some of the food they eat is organic, while 61% say not too much or none of their food is, according to a recent Pew Research Center report .

How many organic milk farms are there in the US?

There were more than 2,500 certified organic milk farms in the U.S., with New York (471), Wisconsin (453) and Pennsylvania (300) at the top for the highest number of farms. Other top organic foods by sales value included eggs , chickens , apples , lettuce , strawberries , grapes , tomatoes and corn . The top three states for organic farms certified …

What is certified organic food?

Certified organic food, according to the Agriculture Department’s definition, must be produced without the use of conventional pesticides, petroleum- or sewage-based fertilizers, herbicides, genetic engineering, antibiotics, growth hormones or irradiation.

What is the 2014 Farm Act?

The 2014 Farm Act, for example, helped organic producers with the cost of organic certification (among other things). More recently, Congress passed an $867 billion farm bill that includes funding for organic farming research.

Which states have organic eggs?

The top three states for organic farms certified for eggs were Wisconsin (106), Pennsylvania (92) and Missouri (89) . The rise in organic farming in the U.S. coincides with Americans’ growing appetite for organic food over the past few decades.

Is organic produce better than non-organic?

About half of U.S. adults (51%) say organic produce is neither better nor worse than non-organic produce, while 45% say organic is better. Younger Americans and those who report eating at least some organic food are more likely to believe organic produce provides health benefits.

What does certified organic mean?

The USDA, which oversees the foods labeled as “Certified Organic”, states quite clearly on its website about its role in organic, that ” Our regulations do not address food safety or nutrition.” Foods labelled “Certified Organic” must adhere to certain rules and regulations but aren’t endowed with any particular nutritional or safety features. However, many consumers believe that the Organic label means the food has superior nutrition and is safer, especially in regard to pesticide residues. This is not true. Studies have shown no appreciable difference in nutrition between crops grown either organically or conventionally.

Do organic farmers use pesticides?

Organic farmers also use pesticides, and the products they are allowed to use are constrained with few exceptions by whether they can be considered “natural.”. That is not a safety standard since many of the most toxic chemicals known are “natural.”.

Is organic food safe?

However, many consumers believe that the Organic label means the food has superior nutrition and is safer, especially in regard to pesticide residues. This is not true. Studies have shown no appreciable difference in nutrition between crops grown either organically or conventionally. As for the safety issue.

Is organic food a super brand?

Organic exists as a sort of “super brand” that transcends anyone marketing under that banner. Unfortunately, within the organic realm there are certain major marketers (and advocacy groups they fund) who employ fear-based and falsehood-based messages to demonize “conventional” foods.

Is organic pesticide safe?

Like all pesticides, these natural options are subject to EPA scrutiny, and so the pesticides that organic farmers are allowed to use are “safe when used according to the label requirements” which is the same standard for synthetic pesticides allowed on conventional crops.

Is pesticide toxic to humans?

The reality is that modern agriculture employs an integrated suite of non-pesticidal control measures, and the actual pesticides used today are mostly relatively non-toxic to humans.

Is there a USDA program for pesticides?

When it comes to pesticide residues on our food, there is a USDA testing program that demonstrates year after year that the pesticide residues on both organic and conventional foods are at such low levels that we need not worry about them.

Access Options

You can be signed in via any or all of the methods shown below at the same time.


The aim of this article is to provide information about crop production data based on large-scale organic farming and to point toward major consequences. National statistics show lower organic yields than compiled in meta-analyses from farm- and plot-scale.


Organic farming has been attributed with many positive features of food production—superior food quality free from pesticides, low emissions of greenhouse gases, efficient energy use, insignificant nutrient leaching, high biodiversity, and sufficient and sustainable food production.

Crop production of organic agriculture has been overestimated in meta-analyses

A debate as to whether organic agriculture could provide sufficient food started when Badgley and Perfecto (2007) and Badgley et al. (2007) estimated a 20% yield reduction by organic compared to conventional farming. Similar comparisons using ratios of organic over conventional crop yields have been used by Seufert et al. (2012) and de Ponti et al.

Organic yields derived from national statistics are lower than for farm- or plot-scale

Few European countries include organic yields in their agricultural statistics, Sweden being an exception ( SCB, 2017a, 2017b, 2017c) providing data since 2004. In 2016, about 14% (368,800 ha) of Swedish arable land (2,579,600 ha) had been converted into organic farming ( SCB, 2017b ).

Environmental evaluations of organic farming must include yield level and demand for more arable land

Comparative studies of conventional and organic systems focusing on emissions commonly relate rates to the area of land cropped. Such studies showed that, for example, leaching losses from organic fields can be both higher or lower compared to conventional fields ( Kirchmann and Bergström, 2001 ).

The view on nature determines reasoning about organic farming

Nature’s beauty and magnificence often determines our view and reasoning about nature including our opinion about organic farming. If one assumes nature to be the most ideal system, natural means and methods are considered to be superior, and consequently organic agricultural practices are favored.

Why are organic crops more toxic than conventional crops?

Organic crops may have to contend with more weeds and pests than conventional crops, so they may produce more natural toxins to ward the weeds off , as potatoes do with a chemical called solanine. Additionally, the use of manure fertilisers may increase the risk of contamination by microbes such as E.coli.

Why is organic farming important?

Conversely, organic farming methods aim to protect soil biodiversity and maintain the various nutrient cycles (e.g. nitrogen cycle) found in healthy soil. Soil microbes should also be present and healthy, as biologically active soil is important in avoiding soil erosion and maintaining a healthy agricultural system.

How does conventional farming affect biodiversity?

Conventional farming involves the use of chemical pesticides, fertilisers and monoculture. All of these practices reduce soil biodiversity and lead to land degradation, as well as widespread chemical pollution; all of which have negative economic, social and economic impacts. Conversely, organic farming methods aim to protect soil biodiversity …

How long does it take for soil to replenish?

Additionally, soil is difficult to replenish; it may take up to a century for a new layer of topsoil to form. Parts of the world’s land that experiences land degradation (Source: Gibbs, Salmon, 2015 ).

Is Sikkim a self-sufficient state?

In response to the widespread challenge of increased pests and diseases, Sikkim’s Department of Horticulture reasoned that ‘we can never become self-sufficient in food. Since Sikkim became a 100% organic state, the inflow of tourists has increased by 25% and we will now also focus on wellness tourism’.

Is organic farming sustainable?

However, organic farming may also result in soils being depleted of their nutrients, leading to a loss in productivity. If this is true, then this would render organic farming unsustainable economically as crop yields would decrease.

When was organic farming updated?

Science Updated on Oct 23, 2019 10:00 AM EDT — Published on Oct 22, 2019 3:56 PM EDT. For decades, the conventional wisdom surrounding organic farming has been that it produces crops that are healthier and better for the environment as a whole.

Where is Siegfried Marth’s organic breeding farm?

A cock walks by cat at Siegfried Marth’s organical breeding farm in Hagensdorf, Austria, October 17, 2018. Photo by REUTERS/Heinz-Peter Bader. Forty percent less, it turns out. Organic farming typically produces lower crop yields due to factors such as the lower potency fertilizers used in the soil, which are limited to natural sources such as …

What is General Mills regenerative agriculture?

As part of their initiative, General Mills launched a regenerative agriculture scorecard for farmers to assess their soil. They also tested regenerative practices on one of their partner pastures that resulted in 68 percent less greenhouse gas emissions.


Leave a Comment